This pensioner spilt coffee on her lap in 1992 in the carpark of a McDonald’s drive-through in Albuquerque, New Mexico and won $2.9 million in damages in 1994. The story became the stuff of legends and punch lines yet it wasn’t till a video was produced by Retro Reports in October 2013 that it was revealed that Liebeck suffered burns to 16% of her body and nearly died. This “touchstone for cases about excessive litigation” resulted in McDonald’s reducing the holding and serving temperature of their coffee from 180–190°F to 170–180°F. It turned out there had been over 700 similar reports of burns incidents caused by coffee in McDonald’s between 1983 and 1992. The annual The True Stella Awards®, named after her, now seem rather inappropriate. Here, indeed, was a case of “You can’t believe everything that you read in the newspapers”.
Two stories to keep beside you
Bono (Paul David Hewson)
This Irishman is one of the world’s best-known philanthropic performers. Having invested £56 million in Facebook in 2009, he’s now the richest living musician. His shareholding of 2.3% in the company is now worth some £940 million. This “face of fusion philanthropy” is rarely seen in public without his trademark sunglasses and created his stage […]
Chris and Colin Weir
This former Scottish Television cameraman and his ex-nurse wife won £161 million on the EuroMillions lottery in 2011 and “believe that things do happen for a reason, and that with great wealth comes great responsibilities”. Chris and Colin Weir set up a foundation, the Weir Charitable Trust, to support small, local charities and as SNP […]
Readers have their say
3 comments
A obviously frail 79 year old boba decides to order coffee from McDonald’s drive-through counter and spills the coffee over her lap. The Safety-first philosophy was not on her mind either, if common sense prevailed she would have avoided the drive-through option, and opted for the safer solution, entering the restaurant.
$2.9 Million in damages for 16% Third degree burns is a very good result. Injured British servicemen must establish which Law firm she used.
Read the story and watch the video Chaim. She was the VICTIM of overly hot coffee. She had her character assassinated and it is only in death that the wrong has been finally righted.
What formula was applied to calculate the settlement amount that was disbursed to the plaintiff Stella Liebeck. The injured party responsibility factor equalled more than 20%. Both the plaintiff and defendant are equally guilty of breaching Health and Safety principles. The plaintiff was in the passenger seat of her grandsons vehicle, they parked the vehicle, there was no cup holders in the vehicle, the plaintiff positioned the cup of coffee between her legs to add sugar and cream ( a act of irresponsibility and stupidity) The grandson made no effort to assist his elderly grandmother. Consumers and service providers have equal responsibility to Health and Safety regulations.