Sunday, April 21, 2024

Connecting justice


The worrying similarities in developments in the cases of Oscar Pistorious and Rebekah Brooks could be very bad for justice


Two cases. Two countries. Two worrying trends. The cases against Oscar Pistorious and Rebekah Brooks might at first glance appear to have little in common but in reality they’re developing a lot of similarities.


Paralympian Pistorious appeared before magistrates today accused of murdering his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, at his home on Valentine’s Day this year. The magistrate warned that he should not face “trial by media” and criticised the “scandalous and possibly contemptuous” reporting by some media following the publication of pictures by the Rupert Murdoch owned Sky News last week that purport to show the blood-spattered bathroom where the Olympian is said to have shot his lover.


Oscar Pistorious in court on Tuesday 4th June 2013
Oscar Pistorious in court on Tuesday 4th June 2013
The blood spattered bathroom as shown on SKY News
The blood spattered bathroom as shown on SKY News

Separately, the former chief police investigator on the case, Hilton Botha, who was removed after it was revealed that he was himself facing separate attempted murder charges, commented that the pictures were not official police pictures and suggested they were taken with a mobile phone. In an interview with the Sunday People, the former detective stated:


“It looks like the pictures have been taken one or two days after the scene because on the Saturday (a day after the fatal shooting) I took it down and sent it away for forensics”.


“This is why I took the door down. I knew that anyone could come in and take pictures and both our cases could be buggered. I also wanted to make sure if there were fingerprints on the inside of the door – maybe Reeva was trying to keep it closed”.


“I’d heard there was money being offered for pictures of the door and that’s why I took it down. Someone made money out of this but hopefully they will be caught”.


Mr Botha is plainly a discredited man but what he says is worrying. The prosecution of Pistorious, whose case was postponed until 19th August on the request of the prosecution today, could collapse because of the photographic evidence that was leaked to the public prior to defence lawyers seeing them.


Rebekah Brooks at the 2011 Cheltenham Festival
Rebekah Brooks at the 2011 Cheltenham Festival

The case against Rebekah Brooks, a former employee of Rupert Murdoch’s News International corporation, equally could potentially be prejudiced if a story spreading like wildfire through Twitter and the blogging community presently is proved to have any substance.


If certain information is revealed, Mrs Brooks, whose lawyer is the Prime Minister’s brother Alex Cameron and whose connections to the political glitterati is well known, could claim that this be prejudicial to her trial. It could indeed scupper the whole case.


We at The Steeple Times have clearly suggested in the past that we think that too much of the blame for the whole phone hacking scandal has been placed on the shoulders of Mrs Brooks, but this could truly tip the balance in the other direction.


For those of us in media circles, these two cases are like the gifts that keep on giving. Barely a day goes by without juicy gossip and innuendo being shared and the public, like dogs chewing on a bone, lap it up. Sadly, for society as a whole though, if the turns and technicalities destroy either or both of these cases, it will set the most terrible of precedents.



Subscribe to our free once daily email newsletter here.

The Steeple Times
The Steeple Times
We research and background check our articles. If you believe we have made and error in some detail please get in touch, we seek always to write the truth and stand against a press owned by a self selected few. Please help us, we will accept all your likes, subscriptions and anonymous suport. The Editor and his team at the Steeple Times.


  1. Oscar Pistorius defence team have a joker in their pack of cards. Former Springbok rugby player Rudi Visagie accidently shot and killed his daughter, mistaking her for a burglar in the night. The similarities in the two cases will be exploited by the defence team. Oscar will walk free.

  2. Pistorious is a murderer , if he ever gets way with it, I will resign for good as a barrister, it is always wicked lawyers pushed by greed who make those monsters walk free, not all lawyers are of that ilk , but stll it has become a dishonourable profession

    • You are pre-judging. A crime of passion is not murder* under Roman-Dutch Law. Even if he just flew into a rage over a lover’s tiff and started blasting away–that is not pre-meditation. That is why the police insistence that he was wearing his false legs, while Pistorius says he was on his stumps. The height and angle of the bullet-holes in the door will be critical.
      *We may think it murder, but in the old days you only swung for pre-meditated or common cause. But there is usually an alternative charge, so he will be done for Murder/manslaughter

  3. You quoted “too much of the blame for the whole phone hacking scandal has been placed on the shoulders of Mrs Brooks” – yes I agree with you. being a witness at the Leveson inquiry about the same very thing but pointing fingers in the direction of other newspapers are where the Police should be also looking. Here’s a link to my blog that explains my involvement and other newspapers’ involvement in the phone hacking saga that has gone on for a lot longer than the public really know.

  4. You may be unfamiliar with the SA legal system. Roman-Dutch–no Jury. Theoretically, professional judges are too cool to be prejudiced by public disclosure of evidence or extraneous information or activities. The Judge’s warning in this case is unusual. In the trial of a notorious serial killer a few years back, every scrap of evidence was turned over in the press on a daily basis and a dramatic reconstruction and a profiler’s deductions were televised while the trial was in progress. In saying that, 90% of trials collapse because of police/prosecution incompetence.

  5. 90% of trials collapse because of police/prosecution incompetence. Detective Hilton Botha’s bungling up of the murder investigation supports your statement. Oscar is home and dry.

  6. Oscar is back in training, with a stunning blonde for support, it is not Anneline Kriel. Shickelgruber was the last name of Adolf Hitler’s father (Alois Shickelgruber)?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

£1 per week Supports The Steeple Times

Help journalism to remain honest & independent. You can make a difference to the world today.


Subscribe For DAILY NEWS

Please subscribe, like and share this unique site, it helps us tremendously. The Steeple Times in return will send you an email at noon each and everyday, that we sincerely hope you will enjoy & look forward to seeing in your inbox.


Trending Now

Morons of the Moment 2024 – Filthy Fylde Conservative Association

As man-pestering Mark Menzies, the MP they have supported since 2008, is exposed for yet more sordid sexual shenanigans, the Fylde Conservative Association yet again prove themselves a bunch of nutty nincompoops by sharing tweets about “vile degenerates” making “sexually explicit” comments.

Lettuce & Jam – Which’ll end up having lasted longer? The Liz Truss lettuce or Meghan Markle’s jam?

As meddling minx Meghan Markle gets mocked about her jaunt into jam and loopy lettuce-loathing loon Liz Truss gets mocked about bumbling like a buffoon about her book, Samantha Markle speaks exclusively to ‘The Steeple Times’ about her soppy, self-centred sister.

Most Popular Articles

The Phil & Matt Show

Phillip Schofield filmed smoking shisha with his alleged ex-lover Matt McGreevy (and pictured in bed thereafter); another image shows the pair together in photograph...

Was Mucky Minx Meghan Markle A ‘Yacht Girl’ For ‘Randy Andy’?

As author Kirby Sommers suggests that the then Meghan Markle likely spent time with Prince Andrew and Jeffrey Epstein before she met Prince Harry, we again highlight the mucky, murkiness and mendacious manner of this alleged “yacht girl.”


‘Politicalite’ suggest Phillip Schofield orchestrated his ‘mass coming out’ after a former ‘This Morning’ runner had gone to the press about a supposed relationship...

Meddling Meghan Markle Expose – Attwood, Hopkins & Steeples

Expose interview with Matthew Steeples by Shaun Attwood and Jennifer Hopkins about the former Meghan Markle watched over 73,000 times in 16 hours since it aired; Steeples condemns hapless Prince Harry and his meddling menace wife.

Ampika Pickston

Oldham born divorcee and former glamour model Ampika Pickston describes herself as “feisty, fun loving and warm hearted”. Now based in Hale Barns, Cheshire...

Justice for James Scurlock

Power of social media proven after senseless killing of James Scurlock in Omaha, Nebraska allegedly by a controversial bar owner named Jake Gardner who has been photographed with Donald Trump.

Nasty NestSeekers

Entitled Hamptons brat Jonathan Davis exposed for allegedly squatting in Sag Harbor during the coronavirus lockdown; it turns out he’s a realtor with NestSeekers.
[td_block_6 custom_title="Most Liked..." sort="popular7"]