Friday, January 28, 2022

Caught in court

Section:

“More than impertinent” barrister Ian West slammed for his behaviour

 

Courtrooms, despite being places where justice ought to be taken seriously, are often the scenes of comical farce. Whilst Rolf Harris unconvincingly sought to win over the jury in his case by singing Jake the Peg and imitating his wobble-board, the case of a barrister named Ian West revolves around whether his “impertinence” towards a judge ought to lead to disciplinary action.

 

Ian West continues to consider his conduct as far from "rude"
Ian West continues to consider his conduct as far from “rude”

In April 2014, at a preliminary hearing in the case of a former postmaster – Mr Ingham – who faced allegations of theft and perverting the course of justice, West managed to incur the wrath of the presiding judge – His Honour Judge Kelson Q.C.

 

After the judge suggested a conference between with the defendant over interviews in the case might be useful, West argued that no such meeting was required and took a very different tack:

 

“MR WEST: I have had all the time I need. I know that it is going to be a not guilty trial. I do not need to go through the short summaries of the interviews with him to change that position. He tells me he is not guilty. We need to fix a trial date. I do not need any more time, thank you.

 

JUDGE KELSON: Do you not think it is an important part of preparation for this hearing to go through at least some of the evidence with a defendant rather than just take his bare assertion? At what stage…

 

MR WEST: Who is saying I took his bare assertion?

 

JUDGE KELSON: At what stage were you proposing going through the evidence with him?

 

MR WEST: When I have got it.

 

JUDGE KELSON: I will put this case out till later today when you have conducted a proper conference with your client and we will revisit the case.

 

MR WEST: I will decide how long I spend in conference with him.

 

JUDGE KELSON: Mr West, we will come back to this case after two o’clock.

 

MR WEST: We can come back to it whenever you like but I…

 

JUDGE KELSON: Don’t be rude, Mr West. That was very rude. Don’t be rude. All right. We will revisit the case at two o’clock. Thank you”.

 

West then attempted to argue that the solicitor who was with him could only stay for a short period but Judge Kelson was having none of it and the exchange continued:

 

“JUDGE KELSON: Two fifteen, Mr West…

 

MR WEST: … With my client without a solicitor…

 

JUDGE KELSON: … Possibly later; in fact probably later, the longer you go on, but certainly you will be here at 2.15pm.

 

MR WEST: You are assuming that.

 

JUDGE KELSON: Mr West, you will be here at 2.15pm. Now mind your manners and sit down. Sit down.

 

MR WEST: Excuse me.

 

JUDGE KELSON: Sit down, Mr West, or I will take this further. Sit down.

 

MR WEST: In what…

 

JUDGE KELSON: Sit down, Mr West.

 

MR WEST: I am not used to be spoken to…

 

JUDGE KELSON: You are an impertinent barrister.

 

MR WEST: I am…

 

JUDGE KELSON: Do as you are told or sit down.

 

MR WEST: I am apparently…

 

JUDGE KELSON: Sit down. Very good.  Mr Ingham, we will come back to this case”.

 

At 2.15pm that afternoon, Ian West decided not to go back to the court and following a no doubt heated telephone call finally returned to explain his failure to appear the next morning.

 

At the hearing, West “made it pretty plain” that he had not seen the point of the afternoon’s sitting and asked for an apology from Judge Kelson. In return, the judge answered:

 

“I think you are an impertinent barrister. Yesterday I thought your behaviour was appalling in open court. I think leaving court when you were required here in the afternoon was monstrous. You will receive no apology whatsoever from me”.

 

West was fined £500 for contempt of court. He refused to accept this and the case went to appeal at the London Criminal Appeal Court. They upheld Mr West’s appeal against the fine but decided his “serious misconduct” was “in total disregard of his duty to the court”. He may now still face disciplinary action.

 

This type of exchange is far from unusual. It’s plainly better to turn off Coronation Street and head to a courtroom if you want to watch some real drama.

 

 

Subscribe to our free once daily email newsletter here:

     

    The Steeple Times
    We research and background check our articles. If you believe we have made and error in some detail please get in touch, we seek always to write the truth and stand against a press owned by a self selected few. Please help us, we will accept all your likes, subscriptions and anonymous suport. The Editor and his team at the Steeple Times.
    Advertisement

    5 COMMENTS

    1. It is the stuff Carry On films was made off…………A bloody good laugh…… It is sad that it is the offenders laughing ………. It is a total disregard for the safety of the general public. The impertinent barrister is laughing all the way to the bank…….

    2. And the Judge who may also have once been an impertinent barrister is also laughing! He is now a more important impertinent legal cog!

      • I have heard of a laughing hyena, now a laughing Judge, what is next a laughing Policeman? Get me the hell out of here……..

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Advertisement

    £1 per week Supports The Steeple Times

    Help journalism to remain honest & independent. You can make a difference to the world today.

    2,791FansLike
    2,068FollowersFollow
    12,040FollowersFollow

    Subscribe For DAILY NEWS

    Please subscribe, like and share this unique site, it helps us tremendously. The Steeple Times in return will send you an email at noon each and everyday, that we sincerely hope you will enjoy & look forward to seeing in your inbox.

    AD
    Advertisement

    Recent and Popular

    Business As Usual Jeremy King Corbin & King

    Business As Usual For Corbin & King

    Corbin & King co-founder and restaurateur par excellence Jeremy King declares “business as usual” and boldly vows to buy his company back out of administration.
    Unappealing Ghislaine Maxwell Prince Andrew Appeal

    UnAppealing Ghislaine

    Former federal prosecutor suggests convicted mucky madam Ghislaine Maxwell’s chances of getting an appeal will have “major hurdles” and will “have to meet a very high standard.”
    Do Duck Don't Crap Ducks Ledges Island Maine

    Do Duck, Don’t Crap – Primitive Private Island On Sale

    Just as former BBC Radio 4 ‘Desert Islands Discs’ host Kirsty Young buys her own island, another on the coast of Maine goes on sale for just £250,000; Ducks Ledges Island comes with a tiny cottage (but lacks a proper Thomas Crapper).
    The Rt. Hon. Nadine Dorries MP and David Cameron

    Moron of the Moment 2022 – The Rt. Hon. Nadine Dorries...

    Tory twerp and gormless government minister The Rt. Hon. Nadine Dorries MP brings shame on the Tories through her irresponsible tweeting.
    Zara Rutherford

    Heroine of the Hour 2022 – ‘Flying Teenager’ Zara Rutherford

    19-year-old Belgian-British aviator Zara Rutherford’s solo flight around the world in 155 days deserves to be celebrated.
    Prince Andrew Charlotte Briggs curtains

    Curtains For Randy Andy

    As a former Buckingham Palace employee reveals that “spoilt” Prince Andrew made her run up four flights of stairs to shut his curtains whilst he sat next to them, we suggest it’s now curtains for him.
    Prince Andrew Pizza Express social media Bernie Ecclestone

    Not So Social Randy Andy

    As Prince Andrew loses yet more responsibilities, quits social media and plunges deeper into debt, we suggest he turns to one of his last remaining chums, the notoriously noxious skinflint Bernie Ecclestone.
    Lady Victoria Hervey Ghislaine Maxwell

    Moron of the Moment 2022 – Lady Victoria Hervey

    Lady Victoria Hervey’s latest airing to share irrelevant claims about Ghislaine Maxwell simply show her lack of connection with the real story; this tedious twerp ought to now learn the art of silence.

    Over a Million Views

    Omid Scobie Meghan Markle Duchess of Sussex Finding Freedom

    Who REALLY is Omid Scobie?

    An examination of the true character traits of the Duchess of Sussex’s PR peddling biased ‘bestie’ Omid Scobie by Nikolay Kalinin.
    Justice for James Scurlock – Power of social media proven after the senseless murder of James Scurlock in Omaha, Nebraska allegedly by a bar owner Jake Gardner who has been photographed with Donald Trump.

    Justice for James Scurlock

    Power of social media proven after senseless killing of James Scurlock in Omaha, Nebraska allegedly by a controversial bar owner named Jake Gardner who has been photographed with Donald Trump.
    Moron of the Moment – Prince Harry – With his marriage to the former Meghan Markle, Prince Harry has morphed into an utter bore.

    Moron of the Moment – Prince Harry

    With his marriage to the woman formerly known as Meghan Markle, Prince Harry has morphed into an utter bore   Prince Harry used to be a fun loving sort. He boozed, partied and enjoyed playing pranks. Now, having married ‘Murky Mucky Mendacious Meg,’ it seems those days are over.   Supposedly, according to...
    Omid Scobie Sadie Quinlan Yankee Wally

    Scobie Orf!

    ‘MeGain’s’ bestie Omid Scobie deservedly gets slammed by ‘Yankee Wally’ Sadie Quinlan for getting her shut down on Twitter; this childish chap should now just ‘belt up, wrap up and shut up.’
    A Massive Media Maelstrom – McCann, Mandelson and Maxwell – Matthew Steeples highlights how the ‘Mandelson Media Method’ is very much in play in both the case of the Prince Andrew-Jeffrey Epstein connection and the renewed interest in the Madeleine McCann disappearance.

    A Massive Media Maelstrom – McCann, Mandelson and Maxwell

    Matthew Steeples highlights how the ‘Mandelson Media Method’ is very much in play in both the case of the Prince Andrew-Jeffrey Epstein connection and the renewed interest in the Madeleine McCann disappearance.
    Plane Perverted – Name of 9-year-old on Jeffrey Epstein lap revealed – Previously unnamed 9-year-old child pictured on the lap of Jeffrey Epstein on his plane in ‘Daily Mail’ suggested to be daughter of billionaire Glenn Dubin.

    Plane Perverted

    EXCLUSIVE – Previously unnamed 9-year-old child pictured on the lap of Jeffrey Epstein on his plane in ‘Daily Mail’ suggested to be daughter of billionaire Glenn Dubin.

    Weather

    London
    scattered clouds
    8.9 ° C
    10 °
    8 °
    76 %
    6.2kmh
    40 %
    Fri
    8 °
    Sat
    12 °
    Sun
    7 °
    Mon
    7 °
    Tue
    10 °